Paula Abdul critiques imaginary performance on American Idol

Paula Abdul became a little confused–or perhaps clairvoyant–during last night’s episode of American Idol.

While critiquing contestant, Jason Castro, Abdul got hung up on Castro’s “second song”–which he hadn’t performed yet.

“Um, the second song, I felt like your usual charm, it was missing for me. It kind of left me a little empty” Abdul noted. “The two songs made me feel like you’re not fighting hard enough to get into the top four.”

Idol Judge, Randy Jackson gently reminded Abdul that “They’ve just done the first song though. Just the first one, “ to which Abdul responded, “I thought you–Oh my god, I thought you sang twice!…You know what, this is hard!”

Abdul also addressed contestant, Syesha Mercado as “Brooke” during another portion of the show.

Judge Simon Cowell noted at the end of the episode that “This is officially the strangest show we’ve ever done.”

The Best of Popjournalism
Law & disorder: Inside CBC TV's This is Wonderland
Law & PoliticsMay 30, 2005
On the record with Wendy Mesley
Media & AdvertisingJan 24, 2004
Caged Wild Strawberries?
MusicNov 8, 2000
The Lisa Loeb zone
CelebritiesOct 7, 2005
Connie Walker on missing and murdered investigations, life at the CBC
Media & AdvertisingApr 4, 2016
Everybody Loves George Stroumboulopoulos
Media & AdvertisingSep 18, 2006
Meet Jann Arden, best-selling author
Books & PublishingNov 24, 2004
Til Schweiger takes flight in 'The Red Baron'
CelebritiesMar 11, 2010