ISPs not responsible for copyright infringement by their users: Supreme Court

Canada’s music industry lost another major legal battle in the fight against Internet music piracy.

In a resounding 9-0 decision, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that Internet service providers (ISPs) are not responsible for copyright infringement committed by their users.

Justice Ian Binnie spoke for the majority and said that “Like a telephone company, [ISPs] provide the medium, but they do not control the message.”

The only route left for composers and publishers to collect royalties is to sue individual users. But expect that route to be a difficult one.

In March, there was a ruling that said file sharers are not guilty of copyright infringement. Famously, the judge in that case said there was “no difference between a library that places a photocopy machine in a room full of copyrighted material and a computer user that places a personal copy on a shared directory linked to a P2P service.”

In Canada, there is compensation provided for private copying. Every blank audio recording media in Canada has a levy applied to it to cover reproduction for private use.

The Best of Popjournalism
Full Disclosure
Media & AdvertisingJul 27, 2001
Connie Walker on missing and murdered investigations, life at the CBC
Media & AdvertisingApr 4, 2016
Inside the world of Perez Hilton, star blogger
CelebritiesSep 10, 2006
Susan Aglukark returns with a new album, attitude
CelebritiesMay 8, 2004
Law & disorder: Inside CBC TV's This is Wonderland
Law & PoliticsMay 30, 2005
On the record with Wendy Mesley
Media & AdvertisingJan 24, 2004
The Lisa Loeb zone
CelebritiesOct 7, 2005
Meet Jann Arden, best-selling author
Books & PublishingNov 24, 2004